Judgment Time

December 2, 2006 at 8:27 pm 3 comments

While most sections of the media have billed Sourav Ganguly’s selection into the Indian test team as a ‘comeback’, it would perhaps be more fitting to describe it as the Bengal tiger’s ‘last chance’. As his supporters celebrate his return to the Test arena after a gap of ten months, even the most ardent of them know that a no-show in South Africa is likely to shut the door on his international career – forever.

No one would be more acutely aware of this than Ganguly himself. He has turned in a respectable report card this domestic season, but he knows his form has not been spectacular enough to carry him into the side independent of his past achievements. Of course, India’s woefully inept batting in the ODI series helped his cause, as also the fact that we finally have a selection committee that doesn’t make appalling pronouncements on “finished careers”.

Ganguly, however, cannot expect to be allowed to ride on past glory for too long. That he was India’s most prolific run-getter for a better part of three years is without doubt – but, at present, this is an irrelevant statistic. He will need to prove that he is amongst the top six batsmen in the country now, and that there is good reason to pick him ahead of players like S.Badrinath, who have been amassing mountains of Ranji runs of late. He can use his monumental series-defining 144 against Australia in Brisbane as inspiration, but it won’t stand as proof that we still need him. Quite simply, Ganguly needs runs in South Africa, not words about how he is capable of them.

Finally, a word of advice for all Dada’s fanatical fans: cut the effigy-burning and Chappell-bashing and let your hero concentrate on performing on the stage he once ruled. And if he fails, take to the streets – not to protest a conspiracy that you suspect did him in – but to give him a glorious farewell befitting India’s most charismatic and successful captain ever.

Entry filed under: Straight Bat.

Of Experience and Judgment Poetic Justice

3 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Stambhit  |  December 3, 2006 at 11:47 am

    As we move along the corridor of indian cricket and it’s so called to be power centers, it is fundamentally clear that it’s not cricket which is upmost in their minds. Be it the chairman of selectors or the present cricket coach of India (yes I repeat, cricket coach of india) everybody is up proving the other one wrong.
    As much as I admit that the bunch of Ganguly lovers are harping more on past rather than present situation (even though they are continued to be branded more and more as moribund, regionalist), I request the other part of this great country to look into the team India as it is now. Irrespective of what these progressive people think, most of the players are not worthy of playing, forget staying in the team by the same logic whihc had been applied to Mr.G. For whatever god forbidden reason best known to Mr.C, these people have continued in the team and the result is there for everybody to be seen.
    The problem is not throwing out the left hander (even if the method followed was as flawed as Enron’s), it is necessarily in putting different yardstick to different people. I cannot fathom how Chappel is going to produce 11 Jhonty Rodes in team India and also fail to understand how without having runs on the board or getting bowlers who could get wickets for you one could plan for winning world cup. It’s good to have 11 players who could bat (increasing depth or flexibility as they put it) but not so great if everybody becomes a tit-bit player.
    I hope, and really hope that Ganguly or no Ganguly these factors are addressed by the self championed well wishers and supporters of a nationalistic team India.

  • 2. Madhav  |  December 3, 2006 at 1:02 pm

    I think we’ll all know if Ganguly has a successful series, independent of what the others in the team achieve. He must realize that when he walks out to bat, he is the master of his own destiny, not Chappel. In Pakistan, we shed a tear for him because his 30s and 40s were better than what some of the others achieved, but the axe still fell on him. But those innings were just a toe stuck through the door and whether or not the door should have been slammed on him was left to judgment and opinion. If he wants his selection to be beyond debate, it’s now time to force open the door with the sheer weight of runs.

    PS: Stam, why have you excluded “other parts of this great country” from the Ganguly fan club??. I was born in Rahul Dravid’s city and now live in the land where Sachin Tendulkar is worshipped, but my favourite Indian cricketer is still Sourav Ganguly!

  • can sachin do a century against England…

Leave a comment

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Tour Calendar

December 2006
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Score Card

  • 7,331 for no loss

Boundary Boards


Blogarama - The Blog Directory
Listed on Blogarama

Creative Commons License
Registered with Creative Commons

Amongst the
Best Blogs in Asia


Blogdup